[slf4j-dev] slf4j on the google android platform

[Darrin Edelman]

Hello all -

I did get slf4j-android working after going through the list here by grabbing the source code and patching it myself but I'm wondering if progress has been made on the issues below so that I can adopt a more official release?

Thanks in advance,
-Darrin

>> 
>> I've run into a couple frustrating issues with slf4j-android
>> that you're no doubt aware of as it seems that some work has occurred
>> here:  
>> 
>> 1) http://bugzilla.slf4j.org/show_bug.cgi?id=173
>> 
>> Given that I'm dealing with a cross-platform library with lots of
>> existing code the '23 character' android limit is a showstopper for
>> me. I cannot change all the library code to use 'simplename' for
>> example.  Granted I see this as really an issue with Android - but
>> still we should be able to handle this in the android port.  This
>> means that I cannot just handle it in the android specific portions
>> of the code - the already written libraries have to properly deal
>> with this issue by cropping the name of the logger - so that the
>> library functions don't throw exceptions.  This to me means that I
>> need to change the StaticLoggerBinder to instantiate a version of
>> code that knows how to deal with this issue properly even when the
>> client code isn't aware of it.  Wendel's solution in the above thread
>> seems a reasonable solution.            
>> 
>> 2) Availability of android source-code from repo.
>> 
>> Given that this is an for me issue I'd like to put the fix in that wendell
>> suggest... use as much of the useful name as possible and hopefully
>> Android comes around and fixes this limitation someday.   I grabbed
>> the codebase from git and I couldn't find references to the android
>> branch.  Specifically it seems like wendell's fix is a decent
>> work-around for the android limitation.  Unfortunately I cannot
>> easily do this and contribute any branches back to the open source
>> community because I cannot seem to find android code in this branch.  Now
>> this said - I did find the slf4j-android code base on the website so I can move
>> forward... but why isn't this in Git??         
>> 
>> 3) Really just a picky thing... slf4j-android does not appear to be
>> available from any publicly accessible maven repository. 
>> 
>> I've resolved this by adding the jar to my project and automatically
>> deploying it to the local repo - but this really isn't a very
>> elegant solution.  Any chance the android version is going to be made
>> available anytime soon?  I'd rather not package the jar as a build
>> artifact.    

> 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://qos.ch/pipermail/slf4j-dev/attachments/20100823/c8130959/attachment.html>